| A psychically mediated placebo? These results do exclude an explanation based on the
common placebo. Since healers and patients are separated from each other, and the
influence vs. non-influence periods are based on random schedules,
the patients have no way of knowing when it is an influence vs a noninfluence period;
differences in physiological activity between these two periods cannot be provoked by the
isolated patients themselves.
But theres a catch: what if patients are not truly isolated from the
healers mind? True, the subjects in these experiments have no normal way
of distinguishing influence from non-influence periods -- but what if they have a
paranormal means for knowing this? While they cannot hear, see or sense the
healer, nor logically infer which periods are influence vs.
noninfluence, perhaps they really do have this knowledge -- on the basis of a
telepathic contact with the healer. At the moment the influence period begins, healers
undoubtedly have thoughts like okay, now I must focus on the person; when the
rest period begins, she or he may think now I can relax. If there is some
telepathic rapport between the two persons, then one (the patient) may simply be acting as
a receiver in a telepathy experiment, unconsciously picking up information
from the sender and then inducing slight shifts in his or her own physiology.
In this case, we are back to a form of self-induced healing - a telepathically induced
placebo effect!
Am Im splitting hairs here? Whats the difference between telepathically
triggered self-healing, vs. a healing truly based on another persons influence,
i.e., based on psychokinesis (mind-over-matter)? Well, there are several theoretical
issues here; but theres also at least one important practical concern. In real
instances of illness or disease, a patient may not have the resources, mentally,
psychologically or physically, to induce self-healings, even given the kinds of
suggestions which usually trigger placebo effects. By contrast, if healing - and not just
healing suggestions - really comes from an external source, then a vital, confident healer
could still input positive energy into the patients organism and restore
health.
So, it would be nice to know if lab results are pointing to telepathy or to
psychokinesis. Given the complexity of human minds, and the different possible
interactions between them, it would be very difficult to answer this question as long as
the patient - the recipient of the healing effect - is a person. But
researchers have also been exploring psychokinesis (PK) on other kinds of biological
systems, which are not likely to self-heal through suggestion, placebos etc.
If we find that healers can induce such bio-PK effects on these simpler
organisms, then theres a good chance that the healing effects observed with humans
indeed are based on a true healing force.
Additional Sources of Information:
Distant
Healing Therapy Helps AIDS Patients
|